Defect #35872


Attendee listbox ordering problem solution

Added by Osman Yozgatlioglu almost 3 years ago. Updated almost 3 years ago.

Target version:
Start date:
Due date:
% Done:


Estimated time:
Affected version:




2021-09-13_11-56.png (28.1 KB) 2021-09-13_11-56.png after patch Osman Yozgatlioglu, 2021-09-13 10:58
2021-09-13_11-52.png (25.9 KB) 2021-09-13_11-52.png before patch Osman Yozgatlioglu, 2021-09-13 10:58
35872-attendee-ordering-patch.diff (1.11 KB) 35872-attendee-ordering-patch.diff Osman Yozgatlioglu, 2021-09-13 11:10
Actions #1

Updated by Osman Yozgatlioglu almost 3 years ago

Sorry for premature submit.

We're using Redmine 4.1.4 stable with Turkish locale. We faced with wrong ordering attendee list at issues as shown as

before patch

I find patch #16730 and generate new one to solve our issue. Our ordering solved like;

after patch

Basically changed some "sort" operations with "sort_by{|user|}"

You can find our patch file. 35872-attendee-ordering-patch.diff

Install details;

  Redmine version                4.1.4.stable
  Ruby version                   2.6.7-p197 (2021-04-05) [x86_64-linux]
  Rails version                  5.2.6
  Environment                    production
  Database adapter               PostgreSQL
  Mailer queue                   ActiveJob::QueueAdapters::AsyncAdapter
  Mailer delivery                smtp
  Subversion                     1.7.14

Actions #2

Updated by Holger Just almost 3 years ago

With your patch, you effectively disable sorting in Ruby. As such, this patch does not entirely solve the issue but introduces other subtle issues. In the two methods you have changed there, this will often results in many members of the list to actually be sorted correctly (by your database via Principal.sorted).

However, at least in Issue#assignable_users, the author and assignee would always be put at the end if they are added in addition to regular assignable users.

The current behavior of the sort of an array containing principals (i.e. users or groups) uses the custom Principal#<=> method. Here, we use String#casecmp to get an order of display names. Unfortunately, this method is not entirely usable with non-ASCII Unicode. To quote the docs here:

Currently, case-insensitivity only works on characters A-Z/a-z, not all of Unicode.

A workaround which might get partly better resulds might be to use something like this in Principal#<=> instead:

self.to_s.downcase(:fold) <=> principal.to_s.downcase(:fold)

This uses Unicode case-folding to get a lower-case version of the strings to compare. Unfortunately, this still is not 100% correct for Turkish characters (i.e. the special handling of the dotless i). However, Ruby does not appear to support combining Unicode and Turkish case folding right now.

As such, it might be necessary to instead rely on the database to sort things correctly instead (if they can do a better job than Ruby here). This might have to be investigated at least for the "usual" databases MySQL, Postgres and SQLite, plus any other database currently supported by Redmine. If we want to go this route, we would have to adapt the list-building methods to only rely on the database for the entire sorting. Additional users (such as the author or current assignee) would thus have to be passed to the generated SQL query and can't be appended later.


Also available in: Atom PDF